• Skip to main content
  • Skip to site footer
James Pence

James Pence

How God is Faithful Through Loss and Adversity

A Deconstruction Observed

Finding My Way Back

June 5, 2024

A Deconstruction Observed, Pt. 25 It’s difficult to describe what the darkest part of my journey felt like. After realizing that the science behind evolution was correct, I went into a spiritual freefall and ultimately found myself standing at the edge of atheism—a place I’d never expected to be. After all, I’d believed in God from the time I was a child and I’d placed my faith in Jesus when I was a young teen. I’d felt called to ministry and gone to Bible college and seminary. I’d spent decades in some form of full-time ministry. God had always been …

Read moreFinding My Way Back

Standing at the Edge of Atheism

April 25, 2024

A Deconstruction Observed, Pt. 24 “I stood at the edge of eternity and beheld only blackness.” That’s where I was during my darkest times. It wasn’t a pleasant place to be. I had believed in God from the time I was a young child. I’d placed my faith in Jesus when I was a teen. I’d walked with him for most of my life. Now, I felt as if all that stood between me and a plunge into atheism was a prayer: “God, please don’t let go of me. And don’t let me let go of you.” Would it have …

Read moreStanding at the Edge of Atheism

Living at the Intersection of Faith & Science

April 10, 2024

A Deconstruction Observed — Pt. 23 It was so mesmerizing, I forgot to look through my binoculars. I’m talking about the recent eclipse, of course (aka The Great North American Eclipse of 2024). I’d been looking forward to it for seven years—ever since the partial eclipse of 2017. That’s when I learned that I lived in the path of totality for the 2024 edition. This would be my fourth eclipse and my first total eclipse. In 1984, Laurel and I experienced a “ring of fire” annular eclipse in New Orleans. It got very dark, but because the moon doesn’t fully …

Read moreLiving at the Intersection of Faith & Science

How I Navigated the Dark Forest of Deconstruction

April 2, 2024

A Deconstruction Observed, Pt. 21 Why I Call Deconstruction a Dark Forest Navigating the dark forest of deconstruction is like walking in a dense fog through territory you thought you knew but that now seems totally unfamiliar. In January of this year I was offered a role in a local production of Fiddler on the Roof. Rehearsals were in the evening, three or four days a week so I did a lot of driving in the dark. As we moved through February and the daylight hours began to lengthen, there were a couple of evenings when I drove to rehearsal …

Read moreHow I Navigated the Dark Forest of Deconstruction

Reading Can Be Hazardous to Your Confirmation Bias

March 20, 2024

What caused me to examine and dismantle my fortress of certainty? You might call it a sea change in my thinking. If you're not familiar with the term, a sea change is usually defined as a marked change or transformation. How did it happen? I'm not entirely sure, but here's my best guess.

Read moreReading Can Be Hazardous to Your Confirmation Bias

Fortress of Certainty

March 11, 2024

A Deconstruction Observed Pt 19 I didn’t choose to go through a faith deconstruction, but I certainly set myself up for it. In fact, I laid the foundation years before my crash even started. The irony is that one (but by no means the only) cause of my deconstruction was the fortress of certainty I built around my faith to “strengthen” it. I was a self-taught Christian for the early portion of my faith journey. I came to faith in Christ through a Billy Graham telecast and my education was through cassette tapes, mostly from Walter Martin (cults) and Hal Lindsey (end …

Read moreFortress of Certainty

Seeds of Deconstruction II: The Rapture Wars

March 4, 2024

Seeds of Deconstruction II – The Rapture Wars A Deconstruction Observed — Pt. 17   After my last post you might be thinking, So, one book on evolutionary creation caused your worldview to collapse No.   I didn’t wake up one day and say, “I think I’ll reexamine everything I’ve believed since I was a child and toss out things I don’t agree with anymore.” For me, deconstruction was something like the story of the little Dutch boy who saved his village by putting his finger in the hole of a leaky dike. As the story goes he stayed there …

Read moreSeeds of Deconstruction II: The Rapture Wars

How Astronomy Made Me Rethink Young-Earth Creationism

February 13, 2024

For years as a pastor I’d taught young-earth creationism. Now, as I looked at Andromeda through my binoculars my worldview took a hit.

Read moreHow Astronomy Made Me Rethink Young-Earth Creationism

The Problem with Buried Questions: They Keep Coming Back.

September 5, 2023

A Deconstruction Observed It was an innocent question but based on my friend’s reaction you’d have thought I’d denied the Trinity. “If God is eternal and unchangeable,” I posited, “how could he take on human nature? Wouldn’t becoming a man be a fundamental change in God’s nature?” My friend looked horrified, almost as if he expected lightning to strike me at any moment. “You should be careful about asking questions like that!” he cautioned. Yet asking questions had become a major part of my Christian life. The year was 1974. It was my sophomore year of college and I was …

Read moreThe Problem with Buried Questions: They Keep Coming Back.

Reflections on Deconstruction

July 26, 2023

What is deconstruction? I can describe what it feels like better than I can explain what it is. Deconstruction feels like walking alone through a pitch-black forest. It’s the unsettling feeling you get when the ground you’re walking on becomes unstable…

Read moreReflections on Deconstruction

Why I Didn’t Lose My Faith…

May 5, 2023

A DECONSTRUCTION OBSERVED INTERLUDE : “Never will I leave you; never will I forsake you” (Hebrews 13:5b) Writing the story of my deconstruction/reconstruction is far more challenging than I expected. I am processing more than ten years of experiences. Often as I write, I remember important details that I need to include in the story. And more often than not, as I explore these details others surface. The challenging thing is that many of these either disrupt my carefully planned timeline or they require adjustments to things I’ve already written. In short, at times I need to step back and …

Read moreWhy I Didn’t Lose My Faith…

Why I Value My Charismatic Experience

April 17, 2023

…and How it Relates to My Deconstruction I completed my deconstruction out of the Charismatic Movement in 1975 with a Bachelor of Theology thesis on the doctrine of the Holy Spirit. For some time after that, I took every opportunity to oppose charismatic teachings and even developed a seminar on charismatic theology aimed at refuting those teachings. But over the years my hostility mellowed and softened. Now, nearly fifty years later I look back quite fondly on my charismatic experience. In fact, I’ll go as far as to say that I treasure it. Some aspects of my charismatic experience are …

Read moreWhy I Value My Charismatic Experience

Lone Ranger Christian

January 19, 2023

A Solitary Christian Life is Not Ideal. Note: I intended this to be a fairly short series on deconstruction, based on my own experience. But I’ve found that it’s difficult to explain the process I went through later in life without fully understanding what happened earlier. So, this is probably going to take a bit longer than I’d planned. I hope not to write a memoir-length tome, but I’ve decided just to continue this journey of discovery and let it take me where it will. Thanks for coming along for the ride. — Jim I was a lone-ranger Christian. Hokey …

Read moreLone Ranger Christian

Deconstruction: Good or Bad? Right or Wrong?

January 10, 2023

Why Some Christians Are Deconstructing Their Faith Image generated with Midjourney AI I started a series on faith deconstruction/reconstruction a while back and then got sidetracked by a shiny object (can’t remember what!) and the series ground to a halt. This post is intended to jump start the series and get me back into the writing process. Rather than go back to the beginning, I thought I’d post this Twitter thread I found the other day that pretty much nails the reasons people deconstruct their faith.  You might not be on Twitter (and lately there are a lot of good …

Read moreDeconstruction: Good or Bad? Right or Wrong?

Prophecy, Cults, and Cassettes

September 17, 2022

Prophecy, Cults, and Cassettes 2 Like newborn infants, long for the pure, spiritual milk, so that by it you may grow into salvation— 3 if indeed you have tasted that the Lord is good. Soooo, what should a new Christian who knows absolutely nothing about the Bible start studying? How about end-times prophecy and religious cults? Yeah, I know. Not a great place to start, but I didn’t know any better. Something had changed in me. I just didn’t understand what it was. What I did know is that I was hungry. I wanted to learn everything I could about my newfound faith. …

Read moreProphecy, Cults, and Cassettes

Veterinarians, FBI Agents, and Preachers, Oh My!

September 10, 2022

Veterinarians, FBI agents, and Preachers, (Oh, my!) “I know the one in whom I have put my trust, and I am sure that he is able to guard the deposit I have entrusted to him (2 Timothy 1:12b NRSV). I never planned to be an altar boy. It just happened. After I survived catechism and my confirmation service, I was standing around at the reception when a man I’d never met came up to me and congratulated me on my confirmation. Then he said, “Altar server training starts in a couple of weeks. Saturdays at 10 a.m.” Nonplussed, I paused …

Read moreVeterinarians, FBI Agents, and Preachers, Oh My!

Childish Faith

September 3, 2022

Photo by David Beale on Unsplash A Childish Faith (A Deconstruction Observed, Part 3)by James Pence 17 Truly I tell you, anyone who will not receive the kingdom of God like a little child will never enter it” (Luke 18:17 NIV). The details are fuzzy (it was 56 years ago after all), but something changed in me the day our priest, Father Clarke, put his hand on my head and blessed me. Or perhaps it would be more accurate to say something awakened in me. Before then, prayers were something I recited from rote before bed every night. And church was just …

Read moreChildish Faith

Sneaking Communion, and Priestly Blessings

August 27, 2022

Image by Robert Cheaib from Pixabay August 26, 2022 – Sneaking Communion and Priestly Blessings 13 People were bringing little children to Jesus for him to place his hands on them, but the disciples rebuked them. 14 When Jesus saw this, he was indignant. He said to them, “Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of God belongs to such as these. 15 Truly I tell you, anyone who will not receive the kingdom of God like a little child will never enter it.” 16 And he took the children in his arms, placed his hands on them and blessed them (Mark …

Read moreSneaking Communion, and Priestly Blessings

Book James Pence To Speak At Your Events

Your group will remember James’s program long after the event. Through music, art, and powerful storytelling, James will share the resilient beauty of brokenness–and how God brings restoration. Click below to learn more or to book James for your next event.

Learn More
Book Now

Quick Links

  • Home
  • About James
  • Books
  • Speaking
  • Art
  • Stories
  • Connect
  • Privacy Policy
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Amazon
  • LinkedIn

Sign up for Newsletter

Copyright © 2025 · James Pence · All Rights Reserved · Website by Stormhill Media